Rate per $10 billion of assets at American Express: 558.5. That is 491.5 above the median of 84 institutions (67). Best rate per $10 billion of assets: 2.8 (The Bank of New York Mellon). Figures for: All products. Period: November 2025 – October 2026.

American Express
558.5
Median
67
84 institutions
Best rate per $10 billion of assets
2.8
The Bank of New York Mellon
Rank
#79 of 84

Figures in the comparison

#InstitutionComplaints (12 months)Closed with relief
1American ExpressPersonal loans2.554100%28.21%Personal loans
2American ExpressChecking and savings28.260398.46%21.16%Checking and savings
3American ExpressOther products29.262499.20%37.56%Other products
4American ExpressDebt collection84.21,80299.61%38.73%Debt collection
5American ExpressCredit reporting132.72,84099.04%19.01%Credit reporting
6American ExpressCredit cards279.65,98198.63%22.77%Credit cards
7American ExpressAll products558.511,94898.89%25%All products

Independent analysis

American Express is ranked here by its rate per $10 billion of assets, built from complaints consumers filed with the CFPB over November 2025 – October 2026. On this scale it is among the quarter of institutions with the highest rates.

Rows in the table
7
Its best comparable rate per $10 billion of assets
558.5
Ranked 79 of 84
Market median
67
Worse than the median
491.5

Card lending raises a rate measured against assets: a card book is made of many accounts with modest balances, and each statement, payment or credit report can lead to a complaint. As a card lender, its rows include credit cards, along with the credit reporting and debt collection complaints that card accounts produce. Disputes over what a lender reports to the credit bureaus land in the credit reporting row.

Highlights

  • Its best comparable rate per $10 billion of assets558.5American ExpressAll products
  • Best on the market2.8The Bank of New York MellonAll products

We would compare it with other card lenders, such as Capital One Bank and Synchrony Bank, rather than with branch banks. Timely responses and complaints closed with relief, shown in the table, are a better guide to how disputes end.

Cons

  • Complaint rate 8.3 times the market median

Figures based on data as of November 16, 2026.

Source and method

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau – Consumer Complaint Database. Period: November 2025 – October 2026.

Complaints consumers sent to the CFPB and the companies' responses, as published by the CFPB. The CFPB does not verify every complaint. A US Government work.