
America First Credit Union complaints
Rate per $10 billion of assets at America First Credit Union: 97.7. That is 30.7 above the median of 84 institutions (67). Best rate per $10 billion of assets: 2.8 (The Bank of New York Mellon). Figures for: All products. Period: November 2025 – October 2026.
- America First Credit Union
- 97.7
- Median
- 67 84 institutions
- Best rate per $10 billion of assets
- 2.8 The Bank of New York Mellon
- Rank
- #56 of 84
Figures in the comparison
| # | Institution | Complaints (12 months) | Closed with relief | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | America First Credit UnionCredit reporting | 22.3 | 58 | 96.36% | 0% | Credit reporting |
| 2 | America First Credit UnionChecking and savings | 23.1 | 60 | 89.09% | 0% | Checking and savings |
| 3 | America First Credit UnionAuto loans | 23.9 | 62 | 83.64% | 0% | Auto loans |
| 4 | America First Credit UnionAll products | 97.7 | 254 | 90.83% | 0% | All products |
Independent analysis
We list credit unions such as America First Credit Union alongside banks, scoring each by complaints filed with the CFPB over November 2025 – October 2026 as a rate per $10 billion of assets. Its rate is higher than the market median.
- Rows in the table
- 4
- Its best comparable rate per $10 billion of assets
- 97.7
- Ranked 56 of 84
- Market median
- 67
- Worse than the median
- 30.7
The rows under All products split its total by product line, so a missing row means too few complaints to list, not none. Credit unions work mainly with consumers, so each dollar of their assets stands behind more people who can complain, which lifts the rate. Credit reporting complaints here concern the account data a lender passes to the bureaus.
Highlights
- Its best comparable rate per $10 billion of assets97.7America First Credit UnionAll products
- Best on the market2.8The Bank of New York MellonAll products
Other credit unions here, such as Suncoast Credit Union and Vystar Credit Union, are the closest peers. A complaint is a consumer's account of a problem, not a finding against the institution. To judge handling rather than volume, we look at timely responses and complaints closed with relief in the table.
Cons
- Complaint rate above the market median
Figures based on data as of November 16, 2026.
Source and method
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau – Consumer Complaint Database. Period: November 2025 – October 2026.
Complaints consumers sent to the CFPB and the companies' responses, as published by the CFPB. The CFPB does not verify every complaint. A US Government work.